A new proposal has been posted to the Firo Crowdfunding System.
- Title: Filipino Community Manager October-December
- Author: LukeFiro_PH
- Proposal type: Miscellaneous
- Link: click here
Use this topic to discuss this proposal!
CFC Members’ Feedback
12th October 2023
Nrsimha (3:35 am UTC+8)
I am not sure how to vote for it in current situation. So will abstain for now.
Nrsimha
I will let other decide.
devwarrior (1:44 Pm UTC+8)
Another 3 months community management @ 300 FIRO … I say Yes; wIth this proviso: I would like to see some Active encouragement of FIlipino remittances via Firo.
Reuben Yap
I would really like to see a more proactive approach
Reuben Yap
I understand “management”
Reuben Yap
Even if it’s a small sum, I’m often frustrated that the community admins don’t promote or bring their community to the events we organise
Reuben Yap
If all admins do is moderate and translate our existing posts, I can get a bot to do that
devwarrior
Reuben Yap
Sometimes I get feedback that oh the community is negative…hard to engage. To me this is self defeatist
Reuben Yap
When ppl join our events even with a small turnout it’s generally positive, ppl are happy
Reuben Yap
If language is an issue, then help translate, we can wait !
Reuben Yap
Or organize your own little events
Reuben Yap
Core team is still supporting Japan and Vietnam but I am minded to terminate
Reuben Yap
We even have a community manager group and I feel like I’m dealing with mercenaries
Reuben Yap
Only Turkish community showed up
Reuben Yap
Instead the monthly update I get from many of these CMs are
Reuben Yap
(where’s my monthly payment)
Sproxet
Is the Filipino community engaged generally? I don’t know how you’d even gauge that without speaking Tagalog.
Reuben Yap
Telegram has auto translate
Reuben Yap
Also I watch their channel
Reuben Yap
Reuben Yap
No translations in most cases
sproxet
I don’t see a whole lot of activity there.
sproxet
Are there other things Luke does?
sproxet
Looking at that channel, I don’t see a lot of value being created there tbh.
sproxet
I could probably hook it up to ChatGPT and get more engagement.
Reuben Yap
Not that I’m aware of. When Luke first started he was very motivated
sproxet
I’m gonna vote nay on this.
Kartal 
Eagle
I will not approve requests from moderators who do not direct their communities to events organized by the core team and do not share them on X. @reubster Please provide information about moderators who do not do these things Their main purpose is to be active on social media and support the events.
Kartal Eagle
Does the Filipino moderator do these?
13th October 2023
Reuben Yap (10:29 AM UTC+8)
Also Luke used to be pretty proactive
Reuben Yap
So I don’t know if he’s lacking direction
Fiend ish
Maybe…
Fiend ish
Tbh I do miss Lucas.
Fiend ish
But that was a big chunk of Firo budget.
Reuben Yap
I think it was also holding back his personal development
Fiend ish
I think so also.
Fiend ish
Still a shame though.
Fiend ish
I vote yes for Luke this time. But if those basic things previously mentioned don’t begin to happen reliably, I will vote Nay next time.
Serious about Firofan though, guys like that, actually deserve something.
Reuben Yap
Well Luke just left the cm chat shrugs
Fiend ish
Ok lol, well I’ll amend my vote to Nay.
Nrsimha, (2:01 Pm UTC+8)
But for example in @firominer_pinoy (Firo Philippines) they get news in English anyway
Nrsimha
After reading discussion here and taking in consideration that in that group:
- there is on average 10 message a day (half of those is good morning)
- Firo announcements are not translated only forwarded from Firo Announcements in English
- users are not encouraged to join community events
I vote nay.
devwarrior, (11:36 Pm UTC+8)
I will follow your lead and amend my vote to Nay also …
14th October 2023
Kartal Eagle (2:58 Am UTC+8)
Here, we act in Firo’s interests as if we were managing a company professionally. That’s why we ask the questions that come to our mind. It’s unprofessional of him to leave the group in the morning instead of responding to me and other CFC members. We are here for Firo. Therefore, I would like to continue with those who can tolerate your questions. My answer is NO
Current update on Luke’s Proposal
Voted Nay
@sproxet
@FiroFiend
@Nrsimha
@Dev_Warrior
@eagleblac
Haven’t Voted
@rasikhmorani
@rehrar
Status changed from ‘idea’ to ‘Disabled’